Moving your online shop to Shopify is exciting, but moving all your data can feel a bit scary. You have years of order history, customer details, and product lists that you absolutely cannot lose.
To avoid the nightmare of typing everything by hand, most store owners use a shopify migration tool to do the heavy lifting.
Among all the options out there, two names pop up the most: LitExtension and Cart2Cart.
Both promise to help you do a smooth shopify migration without shutting down your store. But while they look the same on the surface, their prices, features, and support are actually very different.
Here is a simple, honest look at both tools to help you pick the right one for your store, your budget, and your tech skills.
If you are still planning the full move and want to understand the bigger replatforming process first, start with our ultimate Shopify migration guide.
It explains how to protect your data, SEO, redirects, design, and launch checklist before choosing a specific tool.
Choosing Your Shopify Migration Tool
Before we look at the details, let’s see how both tools prefer to do things.
LitExtension: The Helpful Guide
LitExtension is built for people who want extra help.
According to LitExtension, they support over 140 platforms and mix automated software with real human support. They focus heavily on keeping your data safe and offer predictable pricing based on the size of your store.
Cart2Cart: The Do-It-Yourself Option
Cart2Cart is one of the oldest tools around and supports over 80 online store systems. It is made for people who want to control everything themselves. It uses a “pay-for-what-you-use” setup, which makes it a very fast and budget-friendly choice for standard, straightforward stores.
How Data Moves During a Shopify Migration
Both tools connect directly to your old website (like WooCommerce, Magento, or OpenCart) and copy all your information safely over to Shopify.
- How they connect: To connect to open-source stores, Cart2Cart usually asks you to download a small file folder and upload it to your website’s hosting account. LitExtension can often connect directly using just your store links, which is much easier if you hate dealing with server files.
- Speed rules: Shopify has strict rules about how fast data can enter its system. Whichever shopify migration tool you choose, it will automatically manage the speed so your website doesn’t get blocked or slowed down during the move.
Feature Showdown: Evaluating Each Shopify Migration Tool
A good move isn’t just about copying text. It’s about making sure your customers stay connected to their old orders. Let’s look at how both tools handle the important stuff.
1. Product Options and Sizes
If your products are simple, both tools work perfectly. But if your items have lots of options (like different sizes, colors, and materials all at once), Cart2Cart lets you manually match those options up line by line. LitExtension prefers to do this automatically, changing your old layout to fit Shopify’s standard style.
2. Orders and Customer Accounts
Both tools are great at keeping orders linked to the right customers. However, LitExtension gives you a bit more for your money here. They let you keep your original old Order Numbers for free or for a very low price.
Cart2Cart often charges extra for these basic features.
3. Protecting Your Google Rankings (SEO)
When you move to Shopify, your website links will change. If you don’t point your old links to your new ones, your customers will see “404 Page Not Found” errors, and your Google rankings will drop.
When URLs change during migration, Google recommends using permanent redirects when the move will not be reverted. This helps search engines understand that the new Shopify URL should replace the old one.
Both tools can fix this by creating automatic redirects. Cart2Cart charges for this as an extra add-on at checkout. LitExtension usually includes these redirects in their standard packages, saving you from surprise costs.
Pro Tip: If your website links are very messy or have lots of subcategories, an automated shopify migration tool might miss a few things. For large stores, working with a team for fully managed Shopify migration services is the safest way to keep your Google traffic secure.
Post-Migration Flexibility: Managing the Gap in Your Shopify Migration
A big worry for store owners is the “data gap.” Moving your store can take several hours. During that time, your old store is still online. Since real customers are still browsing and buying things on your old site while the software is working behind the scenes, those brand-new purchases end up missing from your new Shopify setup.
To fix this and close the gap, you need to run a quick final update that copies over only those last-minute orders right before you officially launch.
LitExtension’s Safety Net
LitExtension is very generous here. Their packages include free, unlimited updates for 30 days. If you get new orders or new customers right before you switch over to your new site, you can copy them over for free as many times as you need.
Cart2Cart’s Pay-Per-Sync System
Cart2Cart handles this through a feature called “Recent Data Migration.” Instead of making it free, they treat it as a paid service. Every time you want to bring over new orders that came in during the move, you usually have to pay about half of the original price again.
Cost Analysis: Comparing Pricing for Each Shopify Migration Tool
Both tools look cheap at first, but the price goes up depending on how many products, customers, and orders you have.
| Cost factor | LitExtension | Cart2Cart |
| How they charge | Flat price based on total data | Price changes based on what you choose |
| Extra features | Usually included for free | You pay extra for each option |
| Copying new orders | Free & unlimited for 30 days | You pay a fee for every sync |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days | None |
If you have a tiny store with basic products, Cart2Cart’s menu-style pricing lets you pay only for what you need. But if you need redirects, old order numbers, and help along the way, LitExtension’s bundled price usually ends up being much cheaper and more predictable.
How You Get Help During Your Shopify Migration
What happens if the migration stops at 78% in the middle of the night? This is where your choice really matters.
Cart2Cart Support
Cart2Cart uses standard tickets and live chat. Because their app is a self-service shopify migration tool, their support team is great at fixing software glitches, but they expect you to fix your own product layouts and data mistakes.
LitExtension Support
LitExtension takes a more personal approach. If you choose their premium packages, they give you a real, dedicated assistant. This person logs in, tests the move for you, fixes formatting errors, and makes sure everything looks right before your new store opens.
Head-to-Head Comparison Table
Here is a quick summary of how they stack up:
| Feature | LitExtension | Cart2Cart |
| Platforms supported | 140+ | 80+ |
| Free demo? | Yes (Moves a few items to test) | Yes (Moves a few items to test) |
| How it feels | Hands-off, lots of help | Do-it-yourself, total control |
| SEO Redirects | Included in standard packages | Extra paid add-on |
| Best for | People who want safety and help | Tech-savvy users who want a fast move |
Final Verdict: Which Shopify Migration Tool Wins?
Neither tool is perfect for everyone. It all depends on your data and how much help you want.
Choose LitExtension if:
- You want one clear price without surprise fees at checkout.
- You want a safety window to sync last-minute orders for free.
- You want a real expert to watch over your shopify migration and fix mistakes.
Choose Cart2Cart if:
- You have a very simple store and want to do the move yourself right now.
- You know how to use FTP and upload files to your website host.
- You have a lot of items but don’t need any extra options or help, keeping your costs low.
Conclusion
Apps are great at moving rows of data, but they cannot design a beautiful website or fix logic mistakes between different systems.
If your old store has heavy customizations, custom designs, or connects to outside warehouse systems, software alone isn’t enough to save the day.
Partnering with experts for professional Shopify development ensures that your freshly moved data turns into a beautiful, fast, and easy-to-use store that is ready to welcome your customers and grow your sales.
Related posts:
- 5 Best Shopify Migration Apps & Tools Compared
The Ultimate Shopify Migration Guide: Step-by-Step Blueprint
Ready to grow without the technical headaches?
Book a free 30-minute strategy session with our team today, and let’s map out your seamless, headache-free path to Shopify!
